Mac OS X 10.5 ABF Review, ABFs CXIX-CXXI
Monday, 2007-10-29; 04:21:00
So the new big kitty on the block is out, and it's time for my review of the status of my bugs in this version. Brace yourself, because, from my ADC e-mails as well as two days of use, it turns out this table will be significantly greener than past ones.
In case you were counting, that's 36 fixed bugs (including the two that aren't applicable anymore). That gives Apple an overall fix rate of 48%, 36% if you don't count the already-fixed bugs, and 42% if you exclude the already-fixed bugs and the app-only bugs for iTunes and Remote Desktop. Is that a good fix rate for a major release? Not sure, but it's definitely a welcome improvement from the incremental 10.4.x updates. (I'm again going through and updating all these bugs with their status in 10.5, so they'll get bumped and maybe get fixed in 10.5.1.)
I've also filed three new bugs, because I want Apple to start fixing them for 10.5.x updates ASAP:
CXIX: Dock stack previews for app aliases sometimes display a generic icon plus a monochromatic "do not enter" sign superimposed on top of them, when the app absolutely does run on that architecture, and I can even launch it by clicking on the generic app icon. Filed: 5564739.
CXX: The crosshair when taking selective screenshots (Command-Shift-4) exhibits a crapload of flicker. Filed: 5564758.
CXXI: If you uncheck all the boxes under "Devices" in the Sidebar section of the Finder preferences, nothing will ever show up in the "Devices" subsection of the sidebar in Finder windows. However, the subsection header that says "DEVICES" will remain, even though it's completely useless. Bonus: the disclosure triangle also remains, and is also useless. Filed: 5564797.
Total bugs reviewed: 121; Total bugs fixed: 58; New bugs since last review: 17;
ABF No. | Official Bug No. | Short Description | Status in Mac OS X 10.5 | State in Bug Reporter system | First Reported |
- | 4145629 | Command-Tab switcher does not honor keyboard layout | fixed! | duplicate/2758517 | 10.4.1 |
- | 4145635 | Disk usage and number of enclosed items should be stored as metadata so that accessing this information is immediate in Get Info windows | not fixed | closed | 10.4.1 |
- | 4215588 | Hard drive usage statistics on desktop don't automatically update even though the statistics in Finder windows do | fixed! woo! | duplicate/4106059 | 10.4.2 |
I | 4223711 | Keyboard layout switching inconsistent | N/A | closed | 10.4.2 |
II | 4234753 | Text fields don't always update | probably fixed | duplicate/4020186 | 10.4.2 |
IV | 4252818 | Up/down arrows don't work in Spotlight menu | not fixed | closed | 10.4.2 |
V | 4262172 | Corrupted frame between cursor appearance changes | not fixed | duplicate/4115535 | 10.4.2 |
VI | 4270684 | Dashboard temporarily freezes interface on invocation | fixed | duplicate/4061527 | 10.4.2 |
X | 4300880 | Finder incorrectly reports state of copying when uploading to iDisk | sigh, not fixed | duplicate/3617565 | 10.4.2 |
XI | 4311999 | Customizing date and time format oddities | partially fixed | duplicate/3881433 | 10.4.2 |
XII | 4322243 | white lines through feeds in Safari | fixed | duplicate/3633944 | 10.4.2 |
XIII | 4364497 | excessive grid spacing on Desktop for 10 point font size, introduced in 10.4.3 | fixed | duplicate/4136412 | 10.4.3 |
XIV | 4364498 | iTunes does not allow some info/options to be changed en-masse, no "TV Show" option for Video Kind | partially fixed | duplicate/4272798 | 10.4.3 |
XIX | 4364509 | Front Row doesn't display additional media info | fixed. | still open | 10.4.3 |
XXI | 4394575 | iTunes mini-mode window spontaneously changes to "iPod Synchronization Complete" | too early to tell | still open | 10.4.3 |
XXII | 4394583 | NSTableColumns don't trigger autosave positions of the NSTableView to update when they are added to the NSTableView | too early to tell | closed | 10.4.3 |
XXIV | 4440707 | Finder/iTunes spontaneously unmounts iPod | too early to tell | still open | 10.4.4 |
XXV | 4440711 | NSWorkspace does not select revealed items in Finder | fixed! | duplicate/4021396 | 10.4.4 |
XXVI | 4440715 | Safari is really slow with animated gifs | not fixed | still open | 10.4.4 |
XXVII | 4440737 | burn folders don't always show used capacity | fixed! | duplicate/4377863 | 10.4.4 |
XXVIII | 4440740 | toggling visibility of toolbar sometimes has unexpected behavior | not fixed | still open | 10.4.4 |
XXIX | 4440751 | iDisk sidebar item doesn't always allow dragging-and-dropping | fixed | duplicate/3430977 | 10.4.4 |
XXX | 4450249 | Reset sync on one Mac does not trigger a reset sync on another | Perhaps fixed. | closed | 10.4.5 |
XXXIII | 4480800 | System Preferences hangs when getting list of registered synching computers | fixed | closed | 10.4.5 |
XXXV | 4494729 | Daily Show and Colbert Report metadata are inadequate | partially fixed | behaves correctly | 10.4.5 |
XXXVI | 4494733 | Links can be spoofed even when the text appears to show the actual link | fixed! | duplicate/3465017 | 10.4.5 |
XXXVIII | 4499374 | Smart folders reset their scroll position when new results come in | fixed | duplicate/4131564 | 10.4.5 |
XXXIX | 4547901 | .mac serves up 0 KB blank file | not fixed as of recently | still open | 10.4.6 |
XL | 4547912 | Preview doesn't respect resolution requirements in PS images | woo! fixed | still open | 10.4.6 |
XLI | 4547917 | Finder disk space info gets truncated | not fixed | duplicate/4067164 | 10.4.6 |
XLII | 4547941 | Tooltips disappear after a while | not fixed | duplicate/3237930 | 10.4.6 |
XLIII | 4547944 | Toolbar text labels sometimes appear un-antialiased | fixed | still open | 10.4.6 |
XLIV | 4547948 | iChat doesn't display destination URL in tooltips | fixed | duplicate/3843646 | 10.4.6 |
XLV | 4590712 | 4G iPod loses authorization upon hard reset | likely not fixed | still open | 10.4.6 |
XLVI | 4590715 | TV shows displayed in no particular order in Front Row | fixed | still open | 10.4.6 |
XLVII | 4590717 | TV shows with no season interspersed with episodes of other seasons | fixed | still open | 10.4.6 |
XLVIII | 4590720 | Daily Show/Colbert Report episodes coming with bad episode numbers | not fixed | still open | 10.4.6 |
XLIX | 4590722 | Typeselect doesn't work with the delete key in the Finder | fixed! | still open | 10.4.6 |
L | 4740521 and 4747296 | iTunes 7 main window can be partially resized under non-autohiding Dock | not fixed, booo | both still open | 10.4.7 |
LI | 4740526 and 4747297 | iTunes 7 album art fetching does not replace existing art of lower resolution | not fixed | open and closed, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LII | 4740535 and 4747299 | iTunes 7 album art fetching does not store art within song file | not fixed | closed and closed, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LIV | 4740541 and 4747302 and 4796715 | iTunes 7 source list selection color does not respect Appearance prefpane settings | not fixed | behaves correctly, closed, and open, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LV | 4740542 and 4747303 and 4796717 | iTunes 7 does not respect hidden scrollbar settings | not fixed | closed, closed, and open, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LVI | 4740544 | Cover Flow in iTunes 7 ignores non-hidden scrollbar settings | not fixed | closed | 10.4.7 |
LVII | 4740546 and 4747305 | iTunes 7 still uses modal dialogs | not fixed | behaves correctly and closed, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LVIII | 4740547 and 4747306 | "Remove authorization for Audible account" should be located in the Store menu in iTunes 7 | not fixed | open and open, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LX | 4740551 and 4747307 | iTunes 7 transfers only purchased content to satellite computers | not fixed | open and open, respectively | 10.4.7 |
LXII | 4740553 | keyboard shortcut for Play menu item in Controls menu of iTunes 7 is not flush right | not fixed | duplicate/3227357 | 10.4.7 |
LXIII | 4796705 | cannot bind all documents to older version of an app | not fixed | duplicate/4125820 | 10.4.8 |
LXIV | 4796709 | requesting Mail's Activity Viewer to come to the front simply makes it disappear if it's in the background | not fixed | duplicate/3814607 | 10.4.8 |
LXV | 4796711 | .mac commenting doesn't e-mail you when a new comment is posted | not fixed *sniff* | duplicate/4448408 | 10.4.8 |
LXVI | 4796712 | Front Row does not offer "No Season" subsection for TV shows as 5G iPods do | N/A | duplicate/5024933 | 10.4.8 |
LXVII | 4796713 | 5G iPods refuse to go to sleep immediately after being disconnected from a Mac | not fixed | still open | 10.4.8 |
LXVIII | 5086913 | F14/F15 brightness keys cannot be modified | fixed! sweetness! | duplicate/3301648 | 10.4.9 |
LXIX | 5086919 | Re-sorting by new-ness marks all unread articles as read | not fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
LXXI | 5086939 | Cannot start watching videos in shared iTunes library at arbitrary point | not fixed | behaves correctly | 10.4.9 |
LXXII | 5086947 | AppleSpell process spontaneously starts taking up 100% of the CPU | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
LXXIII | 5086978 | Remote Desktop observation window's size gets reset when connection is lost and restored | fixed! | still open | 10.4.9 |
LXXIV | 5086993 | At first launch, Remote Desktop lists all computers as offline | too early to tell | still open | 10.4.9 |
LXXV | 5087002 | Regular and small size spinning NSProgressIndicators different in appearance | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
LXXVI | 5087016 | iTunes stalls any AppleScript calls when info window is open | not fixed | duplicate/3180284 | 10.4.9 |
LXXVIII | 5090637 | custom Software Update URL must have trailing slash | too early to tell | duplicate/4059544 | 10.4.9 |
XXC | 5090655 | Must use "container of" syntax to get user playlist of source of a track | not fixed, AFAICT | still open | 10.4.9 |
XXCII | 5090710 | no way to get all playlists that contain a given song | not fixed, AFAICT | still open | 10.4.9 |
XXCIII | 5090728 | blank optical discs sorted as regular folders, not as a device | not fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XXCIV | 5090745 | info window takes many seconds to appear if selected item is off-screen at bottom of long list | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XXCV | 5090752 | no "All" option for TV shows on 5G iPods | not fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XXCVI | 5090758 | no "Video Playlists" subsection in Front Row | not fixed | duplicate/4517544 | 10.4.9 |
XXCVII | 5090761 | File/disk in use dialogs don't specify which application is using the file/disk | not fixed | duplicate/2516398 | 10.4.9 |
XXCVIII | 5090794 | Preview save panel always defaults to Documents folder when saving completely new documents | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XXCIX | 5090803 | Preview defaults to "PNG" format rather than last saved format | not fixed | open | 10.4.9 |
XC | 5150870 | Finder's "Go to Folder" sheet autocompletes paths when there are two possible completions | not fixed | duplicate/2492044 | 10.4.9 |
XCI | 5150924 | IR remote button presses don't go through screen saver authentication panel | not fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XCII | 5150937 | iTunes' script menu icon is cut off at the top | not fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XCIII | 5150938 | Preview information panel does not update file size after saving | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XCIV | 5200119 | Remote Desktop cannot control client at login window with Remote Desktop open under some user | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XCV | 5200133 | icons can still be auto-sorted under the Dock | fixed | duplicate/2941011 | 10.4.9 |
XCVI | 5200149 | iTunes crashes when trying to automatically play next TV show in shared library | fixed | open | 10.4.9 |
XCVII | 5230730 | icon size slider in Finder's View Options window does not darken when clicked | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
XCVIII | 5230749 | open/save dialogs do not offer eject button for connected servers | fixed | closed | 10.4.9 |
C | 5260197 | Workgroup Manager grays out "Propogate Permissions..." for root-owned folders | too early to tell | still open | 10.4.9 |
CI | 5274073 | Safari 3 has trouble when mass-changing protocol handlers for feeds from "http" to "feed" | fixed | still open | 10.4.9 |
CII | 5351732 | Safari 3 can't scroll around SVG images | not fixed | duplicate/5069060 | 10.4.10 |
CIII | 5351772 | Safari 3 cannot reopen the last closed tab | not fixed | duplicate/5272977 | 10.4.10 |
CIV | 5351793 | Safari 3 doesn't update feed URLs when they redirect | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CV | 5351847 | Safari 3 doesn't provide access to any tab from the Window menu | not fixed | duplicate/3179480 | 10.4.10 |
CVI | 5351862 | Safari 3's activity window displays incorrect titles for web pages | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CVII | 5383479 | Disabled QT Player menu items are inconsistent for non-pro users | not fixed | behaves correctly | 10.4.10 |
CVIII | 5383489 | .mac sync menu updates last sync date even for failed syncs | fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CIX | 5466620 | Some audio files refuse to display as icons in Mail | fixed | duplicate/4396066 | 10.4.10 |
CX | 5466635 | No way to easily save embedded audio files in chats in iChat | fixed! | still open | 10.4.10 |
CXI | 5466672 | Stop time not accurately obeyed in iTunes | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CXII | 5470356 | Hard to fine tune end braces in QT Player | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CXIII | 5470389 | Can type into AirPort auth panel through screensaver | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CXIV | 5496790 | Keyboard shortcuts can be defined but not used for the Apple menu or menu extras | partially fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CXV | 5496802 | Keyboard shortcuts cannot be defined to open an app or run a script | not fixed, AFAIK | duplicate/2434941 | 10.4.10 |
CXVI | 5527336 | Files which are bundles can't become stationery pads | slightly improved | duplicate/3454612 | 10.4.10 |
CXVII | 5527354 | Stationery pads create a copy of themselves instead of opening an unsaved copy | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
CXVIII | 5527362 | No badge on icons for stationery pads | not fixed | still open | 10.4.10 |
indicates supplemental info available -- hover mouse over the text to see additional info in a tooltip
In case you were counting, that's 36 fixed bugs (including the two that aren't applicable anymore). That gives Apple an overall fix rate of 48%, 36% if you don't count the already-fixed bugs, and 42% if you exclude the already-fixed bugs and the app-only bugs for iTunes and Remote Desktop. Is that a good fix rate for a major release? Not sure, but it's definitely a welcome improvement from the incremental 10.4.x updates. (I'm again going through and updating all these bugs with their status in 10.5, so they'll get bumped and maybe get fixed in 10.5.1.)
I've also filed three new bugs, because I want Apple to start fixing them for 10.5.x updates ASAP:
CXIX: Dock stack previews for app aliases sometimes display a generic icon plus a monochromatic "do not enter" sign superimposed on top of them, when the app absolutely does run on that architecture, and I can even launch it by clicking on the generic app icon. Filed: 5564739.
CXX: The crosshair when taking selective screenshots (Command-Shift-4) exhibits a crapload of flicker. Filed: 5564758.
CXXI: If you uncheck all the boxes under "Devices" in the Sidebar section of the Finder preferences, nothing will ever show up in the "Devices" subsection of the sidebar in Finder windows. However, the subsection header that says "DEVICES" will remain, even though it's completely useless. Bonus: the disclosure triangle also remains, and is also useless. Filed: 5564797.
Technological Supernova Apple Bug Friday Older Newer Post a Comment